• 0 Posts
  • 189 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 5th, 2023

help-circle



  • MimicJar@lemmy.worldtoLemmy Shitpost@lemmy.worldBluesky
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    8 days ago

    Yes you do? If the moderator or admin of your instance doesn’t like something, it’s gone.

    Sure you could post to another instance, but the line of posting to another instance or posting to another service is a thin one.

    I fully agree that Bluesky is far from the distributed haven it might claim to be, but just because it makes a decision that any Fediverse instance might have made doesn’t mean it’s over.

    Bluesky has problems, but those problems are still within the realm of fixable. Fediverse alternatives may be better, but Bluesky is still fine.







  • https://docs.bsky.app/docs/advanced-guides/federation-architecture

    And reading an article from TechCrunch,

    “The social network has a Twitter-like user interface with algorithmic choice, a federated design and community-specific moderation.”

    “Is Bluesky decentralized? Yes. Bluesky’s team is developing the decentralized AT Protocol, which Bluesky was built atop.”

    “However, the launch of federation will make it work more similarly to Mastodon in that users can pick and choose which servers to join and move their accounts around at will.”


    So it definitely is pitching that is it decentralized and federated. Maybe the argument is that it “will be”, but at the moment it is not and at the moment it does not look like it will be an actual possibility.

    Now people leaving Twitter is great, don’t get me wrong, but it’s possibly just kicking the can down the road. In a few years we’ll likely have articles complaining about missing “Old Bluesky” and how “new Bluesky” has the exact same problems that “Old Twitter” had.



  • Oh they’ll be replaced, with “private” workers supplied by Musk, etc.

    The private “workers” will be AI or cheaply paid foreign workers.

    They will be incapable of doing the job, not because they are incompetent, but because they were the lowest bid and lied.

    After 2+ years of doing nothing they’ll need to be replaced by more workers. The government can’t function without them, so we’ll hire twice as many, still paying less than the average American and pocketing the remainder.

    After 4+ years, assuming the administration leaves, they’ll all be fired by the new administration and Americans will be brought in. They’ll have to do 4+ years worth of backlog plus the current job. After these 4 years they be deemed as incompetent and we’ll start the whole cycle over again.





  • In theory it is supposed to be, at the moment it is not possible. Bluesky uses the AT Protocol, vs Mastodon/Lemmy that use the ActivityPub Protocol. Unlike Mastodon/Lemmy, there are no open source AT Protocol servers, and there are no clients except for the Bluesky app, which only talks to the closed source servers. Additionally I think the AT Protocol doesn’t define enough so things like Authentication require something homebrew and possibly incompatible.

    Also, because of all of this, there is at the moment no concept of federation on Bluesky.

    Now, that isn’t to say that someday this will change, but currently Bluesky is just as centralized as every other service.




  • I’m no lawyer but I don’t even think it’s that complex.

    The law as written states “…However, the prohibition does not apply to a covered application that executes a qualified divestiture as determined by the President.”

    It goes on the clarify in a little more detail what a " qualified divestiture" is, but ultimately the determination seems to be by the President.

    Trump can “make a deal” that he considers a “qualified divestiture” and allow the app again. For example ByteDance can sell TikTok to AmericaDance, a new company that just so happens to work for and does everything ByteDance does.

    Now this wouldn’t hold up in any real court, but that would take A LONG time to resolve at which point Trump declares a win and likely everyone just moves on. Bonus during the 2028 election Vance or whomever can say that Democrats want to ban TikTok.