RCS is kinda problematic since the largest server is google and you need permission to build apps for it.
😢
Is there a RCS message app on F-Droid? I’m obviously not using Google messages, currently using Simple SMS messages, but wanted something with RCS.
RCS isn’t as open as SMS, it’s just as proprietary as iMessage, Google has just expressed a willingness to let other companies use it. They’re playing nice because they’re the underdog in the US market. If RCS becomes the new standard, Google will exploit that fact.
Not quite true, RCS (formerly Joyn) was designed by the consortium setting the cellular network standards as replacement for SMS and MMS. It was mainly expected to have the services run at the carrier network - though having it run somewhere else was an option (just like with SMS). Which is what google is doing now, they’re running their own servers.
Efforts to develop the protocol started almost two decades ago, and it was supposed to be taken into use about 15 years ago - but the protocol is just horrible, so the main surprise is that it didn’t fully die, but google ended up implementing it.
They could’ve done pretty much anything at that point - implementations for this were non-existent, and nobody really wanted to be the first to implement it, as - like I said - the whole thing is just horrible. It was requested back then when we started work on the Jolla1, but after having a closer look at the specs we laughed, and it was never brought up again.
Seems like you know a log about the topic. Do you think its better to push for RCS to become the new standard, just because it has momentum? Or would you rather we encourage Google, Apple, the carriers, etc., to switch over to something like Matrix or Signal?
Could you expand a bit on what makes it horrible?
Shouldn’t the EU enforce an open standard, rather than one controlled by a ‘gatekeeper’?
They should. Absolutely. I think the ideal would be that the EU require Google to open up RCS to be interoperable with other standards like Matrix and Signal. But even barring that, requiring Apple to support RCS would be a massive improvement.
I just don’t want to accidentally give Google the power we’re trying to take from Apple. That just puts us back at square one.
I turned rcs off on my phone it made messaging complete unreliable I was sending messages and be notified it couldn’t be sent hours after the fact.
Works perfectly for me for the last 5 years or so.
Seems to work for nobody in the UK all the recent reviews are one or two stars.
Yeah, if there are regional problems with it, that’d make some sense. In US (where I am) it may be a lot more reliable.
…Which also makes some sense as US stuck with SMS and transitioned pretty much directly to MMS and RCS (for non-Apple). And carriers have been pushing RCS.
I’m guessing UK is like a lot of other countries where people have switched to WhatsApp or other proprietary chat systems?
deleted by creator
